“The time of States and justice is additional violence”, judges a lawyer specializing in human rights

Illustration: Palace of Justice.

It is an expected decision that the Grand Chamber of the European Court of Human Rights (ECHR) rendered on Wednesday September 14, 2022. Two French families had been requesting for several years the repatriation of their children and grandchildren detained in camps in northeast Syria. They argued in particular before the European Court of Human Rights that this refusal exposed their relatives to “inhuman and degrading treatment contrary to Article 3 of the European Convention on Human Rights”. “France has violated the rights of French children detained in Syria by failing to repatriate them”, already reported the Committee on the Rights of the Child (CRC) in February 2022 concerning the refusals to repatriate children from Syria. Last July, France carried out its first mass repatriation bringing 35 minors and 16 mothers back to the territory.

It is in this context that the ECHR concluded on Wednesday 14 September that the European Convention for the Protection of Human Rights had been violated. The Court thus considered “that it is incumbent on the French government to resume the examination of the applicants’ requests as soon as possible by surrounding it with appropriate guarantees against arbitrariness”. For the European Court, “The rejection of a request for return [sur le territoire français] must be subject to individual examination”. It justifies this position in particular with regard to the exceptional circumstances which “endanger the physical integrity and the life of the nationals detained in the camps, in particular those of the children”. These particular circumstances are, according to the judgment of the Court, “such as to trigger the obligation to surround the decision-making process with appropriate safeguards against arbitrariness”.

“Why do we have to go through Strasbourg to say what seems obvious to us? »

“I am satisfied with this decision in that it enshrines the right (…) Read more on Public Sénat

Zero artificialisation of the soil: “Minister Béchu of course has the anger of the field”, according to Sophie Primas

Christophe Béchu announces a system for the thermal renovation of public buildings

Price of electricity: “We will not pass on 100% of the costs to customers”, commits the president of the SNCF

Securing hunting: among associations and green senators, a report that does not pass

Aid for oil heating: “The system will be put in place in November”, announces Elisabeth Borne

Leave a Comment